Tender & Crunchy Combo (Chicken, Beef, Carrots & Green Beans Flavors) vs Extra Gravy Pate With Tuna in Savory Gravy
One is a dry food and the other wet. Their labels are not directly comparable, which is the whole reason to convert them first. There is a 70.0 percentage point gap in declared moisture between them.
Nutrition, both ways
Left pair of columns is what each package prints. Right pair removes the water from both. The last column is the difference that survives the conversion.
| Nutrient | A: as fed | B: as fed | A: dry matter | B: dry matter | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Crude protein ranking reverses | 30% | 8% | 34.1% | 44.4% | 10.4 pp |
| Crude fat ranking reverses | 11% | 5% | 12.5% | 27.8% | 15.3 pp |
| Crude fiber ranking reverses | 3% | 1% | 3.4% | 5.6% | 2.1 pp |
| Moisture | 12% | 82% | -- | -- | 70.0 pp |
Multipliers: Tender & Crunchy Combo (Chicken, Beef, Carrots & Green Beans Flavors) x1.1, Extra Gravy Pate With Tuna in Savory Gravy x5.6.
What the numbers actually show
82% moisture against 12% means the printed numbers are describing different things entirely - one includes several times more water than the other.
This is a case where the raw labels point one way and the dry-matter figures point the other: Tender & Crunchy Combo (Chicken, Beef, Carrots & Green Beans Flavors) reads 30% protein on the package versus Extra Gravy Pate With Tuna in Savory Gravy at 8%, but once water is removed the positions reverse (34.1% against 44.4%).
More than one nutrient reverses direction under conversion, which is a reliable sign that a side-by-side reading of the labels was never going to be informative.
Reading the two packages side by side without this conversion would have given the wrong answer on at least one nutrient.
Ingredients
Only in Tender & Crunchy Combo (Chicken, Beef, Carrots & Green Beans Flavors)
- Ground yellow corn
- Corn protein meal
- Chicken by-product meal
- Ground wheat
- Soybean meal
- Beef fat preserved with mixed tocopherols
- Meat and bone meal
- Glycerin
- Animal liver flavor
- Phosphoric acid
- Natural flavor
- Turkey by-product meal
- Calcium carbonate
- Dried carrots
- Dried green beans
- Calcium iodate
- Sodium selenite
- Yellow 6
- DL-Methionine
- L-Lysine monohydrochloride
- L-Tryptophan
- Red 40
- Yellow 5
- Blue 2
Only in Extra Gravy Pate With Tuna in Savory Gravy
- Meat by-products
- Water
- Poultry by-products
- Tuna
- Artificial and natural flavors
- Carrageenan
- Calcium sulfate
- Magnesium proteinate
- Potassium iodide
- Guar gum
Declared by both
- Chicken
- Salt
- Choline chloride
- Potassium chloride
- Taurine
- Zinc sulfate
- Ferrous sulfate
- Manganese sulfate
- Copper sulfate
- Vitamin E supplement
- Niacin
- Thiamine mononitrate
- Calcium pantothenate
- Riboflavin supplement
- Vitamin A supplement
- Pyridoxine hydrochloride
- Vitamin B-12 supplement
- Folic acid
- Biotin
- Vitamin D-3 supplement
- Menadione sodium bisulfite complex